Writings -- Copyright Christopher D. Barth All Rights Reserved
[an error occurred while processing this directive]
Please direct questions or comments to Christopher Barth at chris@arcticwind.com.


Archivists, Genealogists, Access, and Automation
APPENDICES



Past and Present Trends in Archival Access Technologies and their
Implications for the Future of Genealogical Research in Archives


By Christopher D. Barth

May 8, 1997


OUTLINE

  1. Introduction
  2. A History of Archival and Genealogical Automation: Theory and Practice
  3. Relations Between Archivists and Genealogists
  4. Conclusion

APPENDIX A - Survey for Genealogists


Dear Genealogy Enthusiast:

Thank you for your time and cooperation in completing this questionnaire. This survey seeks to gather information regarding the impact of automation on your genealogical research as well as its impact on your relationships with libraries and archival repositories. All information gathered through this survey will only be reported in aggregate to fulfill course work requirements in the School of Library and Information Science at the University of Wisconsin-Milwaukee.

GENERAL INFORMATION:


What is your age range:

_____ Under 20 ______ 41-50

_____ 21-30 ______ 51-60

_____ 31-40 ______ 61 and Over

Approximately how long have you pursued genealogical research?

_____ Less than a year ______ 7-10 years

_____ 1-3 years ______ 10-15 years

_____ 4-6 years ______ Over 15 years

How did you become interested in genealogy?

_________________________________________________________________

_________________________________________________________________

How much time per month do you spend on genealogical research?

_____ Less than 6 hours ______ 24-48 hours

_____ 6-12 hours ______ More than 48 hours

_____ 12-24 hours

In your genealogical research, have you traveled overnight to consult genealogical resources?

_____ Yes ______ No

Do you belong to a genealogical society or organization?

_____ Yes ______ No

  1. How do you usually conduct your genealogical research? (Please rank in order of frequency 1-8; 1 being the most frequent)
  2. _____ Correspondence with other genealogists

    _____ Correspondence with archives or government records agencies

    _____ Visiting a local public library

    _____ Visiting archives or government records agencies

    _____ Searching the Internet

    _____ Searching CD-ROM or other electronic databases

    _____ Other: _______________________________________________

    _____ Other: _______________________________________________

    In general, how would you describe your own comfort level with emerging computer technologies?

    1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10

    Not at All Comfortable Somewhat Comfortable Very Comfortable

    Do you own a personal computer?

    _____ Yes ______ No (If no, please go to #16)

    Please list your computer manufacturer, processor speed (386, 486, Pentium), and clock speed (60 MHZ, etc.) if known:

    _________________________________________________________________

    Do you own any of the following peripheral devices: (Check all that apply):

    _____ Laser Printer _____ Inkjet Printer

    _____ Dot-Matrix Printer _____ Color Flatbed Scanner

    _____ B&W Flatbed Scanner _____ Portable Scanner (B&W or Color)

    _____ Tape Backup Drive _____ Portable Zip or Jaz Hard Drive

    _____ CD-ROM Drive _____ Recordable CD-ROM Drive (CD-Write)

    _____ Modem _____ Direct Internet Connection (No Modem Needed to Access the Internet)

    Do you use your computer for genealogical research?

    _____ Yes _____ No

    If so, for what purpose:

    _____ Correspondence

    _____ Running Genealogical Software

    _____ Other: _______________________________________________

    If you do use genealogy software on your computer, what product and version number do you use?

    _________________________________________________________________

    Why did you choose this particular software package?

    _____ Recommended to Me _____ Price

    _____ Features _____ Don't Know

    _____ Other: _______________________________________________

    Do you subscribe to an online service?

    _____ Yes _____ No

    If so, which one:

    _____ America Online _____ Compuserve

    _____ Microsoft Network (MSN) _____ Prodigy

    _____ Other: _______________________________________________

    Are you familiar with the genealogical resources available on that service?

    _____ Yes _____ No

    Do you use email to conduct genealogical research?

    _____ Yes _____ No

    If so, with whom do you communicate via email? (Check all that apply)

    _____ Libraries/Archival Repositories

    _____ Family Members

    _____ Other Genealogists

    Have you used the World Wide Web in your genealogical research?

    _____ Yes _____ No (If no, please skip to question #20)

    Have you used a website prepared by a library or archival repository?

    _____ Yes _____ No

    What types of information were you seeking?

    _____ Library/repository hours/location _____ General collections information

    _____ Information on a specific collection _____ Other: __________________

    Did the website contain specific information for genealogists?

    _____ Yes _____ No

    Do you have a personal WWW website?

    _____ Yes _____ No

    If so, does it contain information on your genealogical research?

    _____ Yes _____ No

    Do you monitor any listservs relating to genealogical research? If so, please list all related listservs:

    _________________________________________________________________

    Would you describe yourself as having an understanding of current trends in genealogical automation (i.e. genealogical software packages, implementations of the Internet in genealogical research, etc.)?

    _____ Yes _____ No

    Is maintaining an active awareness of current technological trends in genealogical research a priority for you?

    _____ Yes _____ No

    Have you ever visited a library or archive to consult primary source material for your genealogical research?

    _____ Yes _____ No (If no, please skip to question #30)

    What types of sources have you consulted? (Check all that apply)

    _____ Personal Papers (Correspondence, diaries, photograph collections)

    _____ Birth, Marriage, or Death Records

    _____ Corporate, Institutional, or Organizational Records (including church records)

    In general, what types of archival sources did you find most helpful? (Please rank 1-3; 1 being the best)

    _____ Personal Papers (Correspondence, diaries, photograph collections)

    _____ Birth, Marriage, or Death Records

    _____ Corporate, Institutional, or Organizational Records (including church records)

    During your visit, were you generally satisfied with the reference assistance provided by the library/archive staff?

    _____ Yes _____ No

    Did you feel the librarians/archivists demonstrated an understanding of the needs of genealogical researchers?

    _____ Yes _____ No

    If you could use any three adjectives to describe your overall experience as a genealogical patron of an archival repository, what would they be:

    _________________________________________________________________

    Have you ever attended an informational meeting or seminar offered by a library or archival repository regarding genealogical research and/or their collections?

    _____ Yes _____ No

    Would you be interested in attending outreach sessions offered by a local library or archival repository regarding their collections?

    _____ Yes _____ No

    In your experience, are the automation efforts regarding genealogical resources made by libraries and archival repositories meeting the needs of genealogical researchers?

    _____ Yes _____ No

    If not, what how could libraries or archival repositories improve their automation efforts?

    _________________________________________________________________

    What methods of automation are most helpful to you in your genealogical research? (Please rank in order of importance 1-5; 1 being most helpful)

    _____ Online records in a public catalog

    _____ Electronic finding aids

    _____ Gopher sites

    _____ World Wide Web sites

    _____ Ability to email with library/archive staff

    Overall, do you feel automation in genealogical research makes your searching:

    _____ More Productive ______ Less Productive

    _____ About the Same

    THANK YOU!

    APPENDIX B: Survey for Archivists


    Name of Archives: _____________________________________________________

    Location: _____________________________________________________

    Is your institution:

    _____ Publically Funded _____ Privately Funded

    Number of Staff (FTE):

    _____ Professional _____ Student

    _____ Paraprofessional _____ Volunteer

    _____ Support

    Total Size of Collections (cu.ft.): _____________________________________________

    Average Total Number of Reference Requests Per Year: ________________________

    _____ Percentage of Requests Administrative in nature

    _____ Percentage of Requests Genealogical in nature

    _____ Percentage of Requests Scholarly in nature

    1. Please estimate the average amount of staff time spent per reference request for each type of request:

    _____ Requests Administrative in nature

    _____ Requests Genealogical in nature

    _____ Requests Scholarly in nature

    Does your institution have a policy prescribing or limiting staff time for reference requests? If possible, please attach a copy.

    _____ Yes _____ No

    On average, please rank (1 being the best) the following user groups for your perceptions of their overall knowledge of archival practices and preparedness when consulting archival sources in relation to other user groups:

    _____ Administrative Users

    _____ Genealogical Users

    _____ Scholarly Users

    If you could use any three adjectives to describe each user group as archival patrons, what would they be:

    Administrative Users: 1)_____________________________________________

    2)_____________________________________________

    3)_____________________________________________

    Genealogical Users: 1)_____________________________________________

    2)_____________________________________________

    3)_____________________________________________

    Scholarly Users: 1)_____________________________________________

    2)_____________________________________________

    3)_____________________________________________

    Does your repository offer special training sessions or outreach programs to broaden awareness of your repository and archival sources in general?

    _____ Yes _____ No

    If so, please list the number of programs you undertook in the past year geared toward each specific group of archival users:

    _____ General Sessions (without a specific research focus)

    _____ Administrative Sessions

    _____ Genealogical Sessions

    _____ Scholarly Sessions

    Please list the names of different archival-related associations or organizations to which you or other staff members currently belong:

    Administrative/Professional Associations:

    ___________________________________________________________

    Genealogical Associations:

    ___________________________________________________________

    Scholarly Associations: (i.e. AHA)

    ___________________________________________________________

    Does your repository actively pursue collections solely for their:

    _____ Administrative value (Y or N)

    _____ Genealogical value (Y or N)

    _____ Scholarly value (Y or N)

    Which values are most important in evaluating your archival collections? Please rank 1-3 (1 being the most important):

    _____ Administrative values

    _____ Genealogical values

    _____ Scholarly values

    In general, how where would you rate your repository's attitude toward implementing new automated systems?

    1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10

    Not Pursing Automation Some Automation in Place Aggressively Pursues

    At This Time But Not Cutting Edge New Technology

    To what extent do the following factors figure in your automation decisions?

    Very Important Not at All Important

    1 2 3 Applicability Concerns

    1 2 3 Financial Concerns Regarding Equipment

    1 2 3 Staff Time and Additional Workload

    1 2 3 Staff Training to Implement New Systems

    1 2 3 Other: ____________________________________________

    How many computer workstations does your repository currently use? ___________

    If known, please list processor speeds and clock speeds:

    Example: 486 66 MHZ

    ____________ ____________

    ____________ ____________

    ____________ ____________

    ____________ ____________

    ____________ ____________

    ____________ ____________

    Does your repository own or have access to (Y or N):

    _____ Laser Printer _____ Inkjet Printer

    _____ Dot-Matrix Printer _____ Color Flatbed Scanner

    _____ B&W Flatbed Scanner _____ Portable Scanner (B&W or Color)

    _____ Tape Backup Drive _____ Portable Zip or Jaz Hard Drive

    _____ CD-ROM Drive _____ Recordable CD-ROM Drive (CD-Write)

    _____ Modem _____ Direct Internet Connection (No Modem Needed to Access the Internet)

    Are your workstations networked with a local area network:

    _____ Yes _____ No

    If so, is this network connected to or part of a larger institutional local area network:

    _____ Yes _____ No

    On average, how many hours per day does each staff members spend at a computer workstation?

    _____ 0-1 _____ 5-6

    _____ 2-4 _____ 7 or more

    Do you service reference requests submitted by email?

    _____ Yes _____ No

    Do you solicit reference requests submitted by email?

    _____ Yes _____ No

    Do you manage your collections with an automated in-house cataloging system?

    _____ Yes _____ No

    If so, please list the computer software used:

    ___________________________________________________________

    Does your repository include MARC records in your institution's OPAC?

    _____ Yes _____ No

    Are your finding aids available in electronic format?

    _____ Yes _____ No

    If not, do you plan to offer them in electronic format?

    _____ Yes _____ No

    Does your repository maintain a gopher site?

    _____ Yes ______ No

    If so, which of the following does it contain:

    _____ Basic Repository Information _____ Online Finding Aids

    _____ Online Exhibits _____ Links to Other Scholarly Resources

    _____ Links to Other Genealogical Resources _____ Other: ______________________

    If not, have you previously had a gopher site, or do you plan to implement a gopher site in the near future:

    _____ Yes (Previously) _____ No (Never)

    _____ Yes (Will Implement) _____ No (Will Not Implement)

    Does your repository have a website?

    _____ Yes _____ No

    If so, which of the following does it contain:

    _____ Basic Repository Information _____ Online Finding Aids

    _____ Online Exhibits _____ Links to Other Scholarly Resources

    _____ Links to Other Genealogical Resources _____ Other: ______________________

    If not, have you previously had a WWW website, or do you plan to implement a website in the near future:

    _____ Yes (Previously) _____ No (Never)

    _____ Yes (Will Implement) _____ No (Will Not Implement)

    Do you or your staff monitor any listservs relating to library science, archival science, or issues of scholarly and genealogical research? If so, please list related listservs:

    _________________________________________________________________

    Do you or your staff monitor any Usenet newsgroups relating to library science, archival science, or issues of scholarly or genealogical research? If so, please let related newsgroups:

    _________________________________________________________________

    In your experience, what types of researchers are most familiar with emerging technologies and their applications for research? (Please rank 1-3, 1 being the best)

    _____ Administrative Users

    _____ Genealogical Users

    _____ Scholarly Users

    In your opinion, which types of researchers stand to benefit the most from increased automation in archival repositories and tools such as the Internet? (Please rank 1-3, 1 being the best)

    _____ Administrative Users

    _____ Genealogical Users

    _____ Scholarly Users

    To what extent would you estimate your staff's knowledge and understanding of current trends in genealogical automation (i.e. genealogical software packages, implementations of the Internet in genealogical research, etc.)?

    1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10

    No Knowledge or Interest Some Knowledge and Very Knowledgeable

    At This Time Interest

    30. Is it a priority for your institution to maintain an awareness of current trends in genealogical automation?

    ______ Yes ______ No

    In your experience, are the automation efforts of your repository serving the needs of each group of patrons?

    _____ Administrative Users (Y or N)

    _____ Genealogical Users (Y or N)

    _____ Scholarly Users (Y or N)

    Upon what do your base your perceptions?

    _____ Formal User Studies

    _____ Informal Interaction with Patrons

    _____ Other: _______________________________________________

    Do you perceive a need for greater levels of automation at this time to serve each group of users?

    _____ Administrative Users (Y or N)

    _____ Genealogical Users (Y or N)

    _____ Scholarly Users (Y or N)

    In your experience, what forms of automated information dissemination do you find most helpful for researchers in general?

    _____ Online records in a public catalog

    _____ Electronic finding aids

    _____ Gopher sites

    _____ World Wide Web sites

    _____ Ability to email with library/archive staff

    Overall, what do you feel are the most positive benefits to automation in the archival environment? (Please rank in order of benefit, 1 being the most positive)

    _____ Allows free text searching of electronic documents and finding aids

    _____ Permits the archivist to take a less active role in the reference process

    _____ Promotes use of archives

    _____ Decreases retrieval time for archival materials

    _____ Increases retrieval accuracy for archival materials

    _____ Makes it easier for patrons to access archival materials

    _____ Saves money (postage/long distance)

    _____ Other: _____________________________________________________

    _____ Other: _____________________________________________________

    In your experience, do you feel automation has made your job as an archivist easier, or more difficult?

    _____ Easier _____ About the Same _____ More Difficult


Site Navigator:

[an error occurred while processing this directive]
Counter
Writings www.arcticwind.com Copyright